Home » Hollywood 2.0 » wp » written by Pizzolo » Currently Reading:

The Myth of Hypersyndication

July 7, 2009 Hollywood 2.0, wp, written by Pizzolo No Comments

Hypersyndication is a buzzword (a bit long in tooth for web 2.0, but still prevalent) for massmarket online distribution. If massmarket distribution means being in every chain store from WalMart to Best Buy to your local grocery store and gas station, then hypersyndication is its web equivalent. The idea is your content should be out there as widely, freely, and unsupervisedly as possible… so it should be on iTunes, Amazon Unbox, Xbox, Netflix Watch Now, Hulu, Crackle, YouTube, ad infinitum, ad nauseam and also easily embeddable on blogs, Myspace pages, emails, widgets, and whatnot.

To a certain extent, it’s completely accurate. There is so much content already out there and so much new content being generated every second that you literally have to be everywhere just to be noticed. But there’s a dark side to hypersyndication… the same dark side as massmarket distribution.

Massmarket/hypersyndication is for mainstream, broadly-accessible content that requires no context. That’s fine for major studio tentpoles, but the trend these days is more toward niche/narrowcast than mainstream/broadcast. When niche/narrowcast content is seen out of context, it does more harm than good.

An example… Iron Man (directed by Jon Favreau) is mainstream/broadcast. 95% of people who stumble across that movie randomly could instantly be pulled in on some level. On the other hand, Tetsuo the Iron Man (directed by Shinya Tsukamoto) does not have the same broad appeal. Even someone who might fall in love with Tetsuo the Iron Man would probably not enjoy it immediately based on seeing it play in someone’s embedded video on their Myspace page. The viewer needs to know what they’re getting themselves into… they need to commit to Tetsuo the Iron Man before watching it. Iron Man requires no such prior commitment.

Does that mean Iron Man is a better film than Tetsuo the Iron Man. I don’t think so, I think they’re both great at what they are. It’s meaningless to compare them, they have nothing in common other than they are stories on film that we collectively label as “movies” or “films.” To Netflix, they’re the same thing. Netflix offers hardly any context. And once you have a Netflix subscription, the movies are essentially free. FREE means that there is no commitment on the part of the consumer… there is no due diligence required, and thus FREE further diminishes context. As Michael Ironside says in Starship Troopers “something given has no value.” I could see a mainstream Netflix customer who enjoyed Iron Man happen across Tetsuo the Iron Man, think to himself ‘I liked Iron Man, I’ll check this out’ and add it to his Netflix queue… then a week or so later it winds up in his mailbox, a week or two after that he pops it in the DVD player forgetting everything about why he selected it in the first place, and then he gets immediately annoyed by the movie, stops it after 3 minutes, mails it back and writes a bad review on Netflix about how it’s unwatchable and pretentious. That’s a bummer for Tsukamoto… he doesn’t deserve that kind of aggravation.

Most people will argue that hypersyndication still works because a small percentage of an exponentially larger audience is still far huger than a relatively large percentage of a tiny niche. The problem with that model is the Tyranny Of The Naysayers. Someone who dislikes a movie is far more likely to write a bad review than someone who likes a movie is apt to write a good review. If you exponentially increase the number of people who see the movie (knowing full well that the number of viewers it’s truly geared for is disproportionately smaller than those who simply won’t get it), you’re setting the film up to be tarred and feathered on the public stage. You’ll have no niche audience to champion the film, only naysayers hating on it… and most consumers can’t discern the comments of people who ‘don’t get it’ from people who ‘do get it.’

Some of the coolest, most exciting, most compelling films simply should not be seen by everyone. They’re great films, and they’re not for everybody. That statement flies in the face of the given wisdom about great films… about Oscars and box office and the meritocracy of great storytelling. Being a best-seller requires appealing to the widest possible audience–sure that can mean it’s a great transcendent film that every human being can relate to, but more often it means that it’s lowest common denominator cotton candy. There’s nothing wrong with cotton candy, but is it a better made food than sushi? Not everyone likes sushi… and even people who may like sushi wouldn’t like it if I put it on a stick and sold it to them at a theme park next to the funnel cakes and cotton candy.

One of my first questions to filmmakers is “who is the audience of this movie?” The answer is generally some variation on “people who love great films.” That is not a type of person. Iron Man is a great film. Tetsuo the Iron Man is a great film. If your audience is people who love BOTH movies, then your audience is smaller than you think.

Scarcity creates value. It’s better to build a core fanbase and grow your audience from there than to hypersyndicate and try to reach the largest possible audience as quickly as possible.

[BTW- before I get called out on the fact that Tetsuo the Iron Man is generally favorably reviewed on Netflix (despite it being a lower score than Iron Man or even the dreadful Invincible Iron Man animated movie), let me just point out I was using Tetsuo the Iron Man as an example that most readers could easily identify (and also I was being a bit clever, sue me). Tetsuo the Iron Man was not hypersyndicated upon its initial release back in the 90s, so by the time Netflix came along Tetsuo had already protected itself with a core following and a cineaste pedigree... precisely what I'm suggesting you do before you consider hypersyndicating. Also, I recognize Netflix has the 'Ratings of Users Like You' addition to the ratings system, which is an appreciated effort but not a silver bullet for the problems faced by content creators/suppliers.]

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks

Comment on this Article:







Visit some of our projects

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

Recent Comments

  • Ryan O: Great article. Or "post" as you kids call it these days. Esp...
  • Humble Mac User: Damn the popularity of the iPhone. I don't really give a shi...
  • vik: Good idea. Thanks...
  • Mike Jones: I hear ya... FCP7 is not just a profound disappointment, it'...
  • Pizzolo: Comic Con is kind of the inverse of a pregnancy test. Gen...

RSS Halo-8 news blog

RSS Godkiller news blog

Become a Member

Hollywood-2.0 features a new members-only section of Premium Content: actionable information on how to effectively Develop, Produce, Distribute, and Market your project. Click here for more information.

Premium Content

H2.0 the book – Chapter 1: The Producer-Marketer

July 9, 2009

H2.0 the book – Chapter 1: The Producer-Marketer

This is the first chapter of our work-in-progress book “Hollywood-2.0: An Actionable System for Developing, Producing, Distributing, & Marketing Your Project in a Changing Media Landscape.”
Chapter 1 is titled “The Long Tail of Death, The Evil Aggregator Empire, The Decline of Distribution, and You: The Producer-Marketer.” While we pride ourselves on this book’s commitment to [...]

Featured Stories

Sorry, Comics, But You’re Fucked

April 24, 2010

Sorry, Comics, But You’re Fucked

The iPad is great news for comics junkies who aren’t yet overstimulated by too much digital content and for comics creators who see their stories as loss leaders for movies and action figures… the rest of you are fucked.

Don’t call it a comeback, I’ve been here for years.

January 7, 2010

Don’t call it a comeback, I’ve been here for years.

I bailed on this blog in the middle of last year because I got too busy to think. I really was too busy to think for a while, then I just got lazy. But then Pizzolo busted my balls and said that people actually like this blog, and that I’m easier to deal with when [...]

There’s a bridge from the Internet to your TV–Steve Jobs & Bill Gates are the trolls under it

July 15, 2009

There’s a bridge from the Internet to your TV–Steve Jobs & Bill Gates are the trolls under it

It’s like if you and I wanted to hang out and there’s a perfectly safe path between our houses, but Steve Jobs and Bill Gates erected bridges and demanded we pay tolls and they spent millions marketing their bridges so we think we have to take them… but their bridges aren’t crossing a raging river, they’re just crossing a path that’s actually EASIER for us to take than their stupid bridges.

I’m an Internet Filmmaking Millionaire and SO CAN YOU!

July 3, 2009

I’m an Internet Filmmaking Millionaire and SO CAN YOU!

There have always been indie film snake oil salesmen. Back in the heyday of the 90s Indie Film Boom there were gazillions of books telling you how if you just sold your car, sold your blood, or sold out your family’s mortgage you too could sell a film at Sundance and be an overnight multi-millionaire. [...]

Making An Illustrated Film – Godkiller

June 30, 2009

Making An Illustrated Film – Godkiller

This week I’m back to work on “Godkiller,” Halo-8’s first Illustrated Film. An Illustrated Film is a highly stylized animated movie that mixes original graphic novel illustrations with motion graphics and dramatic voice performances to create an edgy new style of story telling. Its like Liquid Television meets Ralph Bakshi, allowing us to tackle stories [...]

Video Cinematic

Don’t call it a comeback, I’ve been here for years.

January 7, 2010

Don’t call it a comeback, I’ve been here for years.

I bailed on this blog in the middle of last year because I got too busy to think. I really was too busy to think for a while, then I just got lazy. But then Pizzolo busted my balls and said that people actually like this blog, and that I’m easier to deal with when [...]

Worm In The Apple

August 17, 2009

Worm In The Apple

Apple has long made a selling point out of its supposedly virus proof operating system. I vaguely remember running some version of Norton on my Mac based Avid’s back in the late 1990s, but that went away with OSX. I don’t know anything about the dissemination of malicious code, but I’ve always assumed that there [...]

Video Color Grading – The Sober Truth

August 14, 2009

Video Color Grading – The Sober Truth

My first year in Los Angeles, I spent 7 or 8 months as a Telecine assistant in the Valley. The shop was a really low budget operation without many clients, or much working equipment, and the colorist that trained me was a drunk. He would roll in sometime after 10:30 each day, and, teaching through [...]

Final Cut Pro 7 – I Want To Believe

August 12, 2009

Final Cut Pro 7 – I Want To Believe

It seems like I’ve been doing a lot of Apple bashing lately. There was my post about the American Cinematic Editors vs. Final Cut Pro, and a couple weeks before that I predicted the imminent death of Final Cut Pro. I’m not not coming down on the products they provide, but I do have a [...]

Brand Cameron

August 10, 2009

Brand Cameron

James Cameron made a big splash at Comic Con San Diego by previewing 24 minutes of Avatar for an eagerly receptive audience. Cameron has been hyping the 3D imaging technology behind Avatar for the last two years, only to spend the last 6 months tempering expectations in advance of the Comic Con preview. The preview [...]

Hollywood 2.0

Sorry, Comics, But You’re Fucked

April 24, 2010

Sorry, Comics, But You’re Fucked

The iPad is great news for comics junkies who aren’t yet overstimulated by too much digital content and for comics creators who see their stories as loss leaders for movies and action figures… the rest of you are fucked.

10s & 1s: Not Getting Bad Reviews? Try Harder.

October 15, 2009

10s & 1s: Not Getting Bad Reviews? Try Harder.

Good reviews are better than mediocre reviews, but if you’re not getting bad reviews then I have two words of advice for you: try harder.

The Curse of A FILM BY…

September 15, 2009

The Curse of A FILM BY…

There’s been a long-running debate on directors taking (demanding?) the “A Film By” credit on movie key art. I’m kind of indifferent to it. I personally don’t take the credit but that’s just me… hell, I’d prefer all my work be anonymous if I could effectively produce & market that way. So I don’t have a dog in this race, but I do have a unique observation on the whole thing…

If you can’t be the guest of honor, be the one who doesn’t belong there

August 23, 2009

If you can’t be the guest of honor, be the one who doesn’t belong there

In my opinion, there are two reasons to be someplace: be the guest of honor or be the one who doesn’t belong there.
Example: I was lucky enough to be included in the Horror Comics Into Film panel Peter Katz organized at Comic Con last month. At risk of hurting my fellow panelists’ feelings, I imagine [...]

All Marketing Is Local

July 31, 2009

All Marketing Is Local

Your job is to cultivate a core following that cares about your message and what you do, and will support you with cash-purchases and positive word of mouth as you create your body of work. That process cannot be outsourced to spambots and massmarket advertising, it can only be done one personal connection at a time. Only once you’ve built that support network can you potentially benefit from the wholesale-politicking of massmarket distribution.